First Edition
Book Reviews
This volume by Jerry Hartzler, subtitled 'A History of the Kishacoquillas Railway' could be one of
the classic shortline history sleepers of our time. It encapsulates all of the rich warmth of an old
diary rescued from a musty trunk in the attic of an historic Victorian
mansion, faithfully chronicled by an appreciative citizen of this sleepy
old town in the Pennsylvania mountains. Yet it has been enhanced with excellent technical data,
charts and fine hand turned graphics to delight even the most critical historian searching for a
classic history of a rural short line.
Without losing any of the solid strength of the thread of the woof of this well woven account of the business of creating and operating this railroad, the book charms the reader with a warp of brilliant personal vignettes of the characters playing their roles from its rise to its ultimate fall. Once it was scanned for the quality of its printing and binding, which, incidentally, is adequate but hardly worthy of its narrative, I could not put it down. My all-consuming interest was held by the Norman Rockwellesque word pictures and a fascinating collection of fine old family album illustrations of remarkable brilliance for their age.
The final touch was the excellence of the maps, in a format which has long been sought by devoted railroad historians. By matching a line drawn map on the right hand page almost as an overlay to the aerial photograph on the left hand page, the author gives the reader a clear understanding of the relationship of the topography and architecture, to the railroad's trackwork and facilities. The rosters of motive power and rolling stock are excellent with complete traceability thanks to the thorough bibliography.
When this delightful experience ended, the volume seemed more worthy of tooled leather, gold foil embossed covers and spine, and gilt edged pages, than paper bindings. I felt forced to make a whimsical decision as to whether to place it in the railroad section, or somewhere between "Our Town" and "Life On The Mississippi" with the true classics. For those who want a quintessential age-of-steam shortline history, this book is a must! <less>
Without losing any of the solid strength of the thread of the woof of this well woven account of the business of creating and operating this railroad, the book charms the reader with a warp of brilliant personal vignettes of the characters playing their roles from its rise to its ultimate fall. Once it was scanned for the quality of its printing and binding, which, incidentally, is adequate but hardly worthy of its narrative, I could not put it down. My all-consuming interest was held by the Norman Rockwellesque word pictures and a fascinating collection of fine old family album illustrations of remarkable brilliance for their age.
The final touch was the excellence of the maps, in a format which has long been sought by devoted railroad historians. By matching a line drawn map on the right hand page almost as an overlay to the aerial photograph on the left hand page, the author gives the reader a clear understanding of the relationship of the topography and architecture, to the railroad's trackwork and facilities. The rosters of motive power and rolling stock are excellent with complete traceability thanks to the thorough bibliography.
When this delightful experience ended, the volume seemed more worthy of tooled leather, gold foil embossed covers and spine, and gilt edged pages, than paper bindings. I felt forced to make a whimsical decision as to whether to place it in the railroad section, or somewhere between "Our Town" and "Life On The Mississippi" with the true classics. For those who want a quintessential age-of-steam shortline history, this book is a must! <less>
H. Charles Yaeger, The Short Line
A well written and carefully researched history of a "backwoods" short line in the heart of
Pennsylvania. Ample attention is given to finances, passenger service, personnel, anecdotes,
disasters, trackage rights, the K.V.
Studebaker rail car and the final abandonment in 1940 after 47 years of life. One of the most
enjoyable railroad histories that we have seen.
Railroad & Transportation Items
This seems to be a good year for new books on vanished Pennsylvania short lines. The
H&BTM RR
series is started, the Bellefonte Central RR will be getting
a book-length treatment, and now the story of the Kishacoquillas Valley
RR is in print. No, it was not narrow gauge, but the "Ol'
Hook & Eye" was hard to beat for shortline charm.
<more>
George N. Pierson, The Scale Coupler
Over on the other side of Jacks Mountain, in Big Valley, the 9 1/2 mile Kishacoquillas Valley
Railroad connected Belleville with the outside world at Reedsville and Lewistown from 1892 to 1940.
Now, 48 years after the 48-year-old standard gauge road was abandoned, a new 170-page six by nine
inch booklet provides a thoroughly informative and entertaining look at the
KVRR.
<more>
Frank Kyper, Huntingdon Daily News
From the backwoods of Pennsylvania comes The Ol' Hook & Eye - A History of the Kishocoquillas
Valley Railroad. Author John G. Hartzler begins by teaching us how to pronounce this railroad's
Indian name, then waxes wonderfully nostalgic about the
KV...
<more>
Railfan
When the passengers of Amtrak's Pennsylvanian or Broadway Limited pause at the Lewistown, Pa.
station west of Harrisburg on the old Pennsylvania Railroad mainline, no train of the
Kishacoquillas Valley Railroad is waiting at the station, nor has one been for many years.
But from 1928 to 1940, the KV ran passenger trains over the
PRR branch that joined the main line
at Lewistown...
<more>
Richard G. Prince, The "Bulletin" (National Railway Historical Society)
"The Ol' Hook & Eye," subtitled "A History of the Kishacoquillas Valley Railroad" is an
interesting new (1988) book by John G. Hartzler. The book has 170 9"x6" pages, printed on good
quality coated stock. It is professionally typset, with an attractive typeface and 110 very
well-reproduced photographs...
<more>
Jeffrey R. Orenstein The Keystone (Pennsylvania Railroad Technical & Historical Society)
The Kishacoquillas Valley Railroad was a shortline that ran in the state of Pennsylvania, northwest
of Harrisburg, Southeast of State College. It ran from Belleville to Reedsville, a distance of nine
miles and existed from 1893 until 1940. <more>
The Scale Coupler
The nine-mile Kishacoquillas Valley served agricultural, forestry and later manufacturing needs of
the small central Pennsylvania town of Belleville, near Lewistown, connecting with the Pennsylvania
Railroad at Reedsville. <more>
Thomas T. Taber III, Railroad History (The Railway & Locomotive Historical Society)



